ROME, Italy / EuroWire.IO / – Meta said it would appeal an 805 million euro ($880 million) fine imposed by Italy’s data protection authority, which found that Facebook accessed users’ photos without their specific consent. The regulator, known as the Garante, announced the penalty on Saturday, November 14. A Meta spokesperson said “we strongly disagree” with the assessment “and the disproportionate level of the fine”. The fine targets Meta Platforms Ireland.

According to the Garante, the Facebook application for Android devices accessed photographs, videos and related metadata of Italian users “without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them”, AFP reported. The case concerns a feature that suggests photos from a user’s phone gallery for posting on Facebook. The feature has been available since 2023. The regulator said about 20 million Android users in Italy could be affected, and that the infringement was continuing for those who had not updated the app.
Meta argued that the feature only works after users give permission on their devices, which they can withdraw at any time. The company also said it does not use gallery content to train artificial intelligence models, a question the investigation did not examine. The penalty is equal to about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide turnover, according to reports. The parent of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp can contest the decision in court.
60 days to change the feature
The Garante ordered Meta to make the gallery feature switched off by default within 60 days and to ask users for separate and specific consent. If the deadline is missed, the feature cannot be enabled for anyone who has not given valid consent. The ruling is based on Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. It does not rely on the GDPR.
Article 122 requires consent before an app or service accesses information stored on a user’s device. According to reports, the rule applies even when no photo is uploaded to Facebook. The case highlights how regulators view access to private files on smartphones, which often hold large amounts of personal data. Similar rules apply across the EU under the ePrivacy Directive. Users can review and change app permissions in their phone settings at any time.
European pressure on big tech
Meta has faced a series of large privacy penalties in Europe. In 2023, Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined the company a record €1.2 billion over transfers of European users’ data to the United States. Italy’s Garante has also acted against other tech firms, temporarily blocking ChatGPT in 2023 and later fining OpenAI €15 million. Meta is based in Menlo Park, California. Its European operations are run from Dublin.
EU regulators are also using new digital rules to rein in large platforms. Earlier this year, TikTok was told to curb addictive design or face fines under the Digital Services Act. In Denmark, authorities reviewed access to the CPR register after a data exposure hit millions. The Garante’s decision can be challenged before Italian courts. Meta has 60 days to comply. Other EU privacy regulators apply the same ePrivacy rules in their countries.
